Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Information may change over time and should be verified with official providers. We are not responsible for any decisions made based on this content.
Pet Insurance for First Time Dog Owners: The Complete Guide
Bringing a dog home for the first time requires many new considerations, including whether to buy pet insurance. Often, this decision is put off until something goes wrong. This guide will help readers understand what pet insurance entails, what it costs, and covers a number of things not addressed in most laymen’s guides, such as waiting periods for orthopedic problems, bilateral exclusions, and reimbursement calculations, among others.
At the same time, one should not take the information provided here as a suggestion to purchase a specific policy or use a specific provider. Coverage terms, costs, and exclusions depend on the insurance company, the state of residence, and the pet, thus this guide aims to help readers ask the right questions rather than make the choice for them.
Quick Answer
Pet insurance is a kind of product that is reimbursement-based, offering financial cover for vet expenses for either an accident-related issue or illness, which depends on the type of policy chosen by a person. As for purchasing insurance for a puppy or a dog, it can be bought when a dog is properly aged, which is 6-8 weeks old, and many companies suggest that people buy insurance coverage before the first vet visit because the information obtained during such a visit can be classified as pre-existing.
There might be a great difference in the prices, as the average price in 2021 was about $836 at NAPHIA (but the actual quote might vary depending on a dog’s breed and age). Whether getting insurance for one’s dog is reasonable or not depends on one’s risk attitude and the animal’s breed-related health concerns.
Source: WhiskerCover
Key Takeaways
- While pet insurance may lessen the financial burden due to accidents and unforeseen diseases, it generally does not cover regular or preventive care unless you opt for a wellness rider.
- Notably, several insurers bring up the importance of registering prior to your dog’s very first visit to the veterinarian, because examination notes from that very first appointment may set the basis for what will be categorized as pre-existing later on.
- Waiting periods vary from case to case; for example, orthopedic conditions such as hip dysplasia or cruciate ligament injury have waiting periods that usually are longer than 6 months, in addition to the standard 14-day illness wait.
- Receiving “80%” in reimbursement does not automatically mean that you will be getting back 80% of your total expenses, as such things as exam costs, non-eligible costs, and deductibles are generally deducted beforehand.
- Actually, there is no single publicly available claim denial rate, so be careful interpreting percentages you meet elsewhere.
What Pet Insurance Actually Is (and Isn’t)
Essentially, pet insurance as such is a product based on reimbursement whereby pet owners pay the vet and subsequently submit their bills to earn reimbursement from the insurer, which will vary depending on the deductible, compensation percentage paid, and the annual limit that has been set. This makes pet insurance different from human health insurance, which is usually under a provider network system whereby healthcare providers get compensated directly. Most of the pet insurers do not employ networks, meaning one can go to any licensed veterinarian, including specialists, according to frequently asked questions published by companies offering services like ASPCA Pet Health Insurance.
What pet insurance is not continues to be an important thing to note regarding pet insurance in that it is not a savings account or a guarantee of cost coverage or an insurance plan in the usual sense of the word.
How Much Pet Insurance May Cost for a New Dog
The figures listed below depend on the source of information and date and should only serve as approximate figures and not as an actual quote based on your own requirements.
| Metric | Reported Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Average U.S. accident-and-illness premium (dogs) | ~$836/year (~$70/month) | NAPHIA data via WhiskerCover, 2025 |
| Total North American pets insured (2025) | ~7.6 million | NAPHIA 2026 State of the Industry Report, reported by Insurance Business |
| Share of U.S. pets currently insured | ~4.27% (5.99% of dogs, 2.29% of cats) | Insurance Business, citing NAPHIA |
| U.S. gross written premium (2024) | ~$5.2 billion, up 20.8% year over year | NAPHIA |
| Pets insured, U.S. + Canada (2023 → 2024) | 6.25 million → 7.03 million (+12.2%) | NAPHIA Industry Data |
Your final quote may depend on several variables: dog breed and age, your place of residence, the kind of deductible and the reimbursement percentage you decide on choosing and whether you want to add a wellness rider or not.
What Pet Insurance Typically Covers — and What It Usually Doesn’t
The coverage details vary depending on the insurance provider and the tier you choose, but the standard setup is similar across most accident-and-illness insurance plans.
| Generally Covered (Accident & Illness Plans) | Generally Not Covered |
|---|---|
| Accidental injuries (fractures, cuts, foreign object ingestion) | Pre-existing conditions |
| Illnesses (infections, allergies, GI issues) | Routine/preventive care (unless a wellness add-on is purchased) |
| Diagnostics (X-rays, bloodwork, imaging) | Cosmetic or elective procedures |
| Surgery and hospitalization | Breeding, pregnancy, and whelping costs |
| Some hereditary and congenital conditions, subject to conditions explained below | Grooming |
This is a general principle and not necessarily the case for every company – some may cover what others don’t; for instance, accident-only plans often leave out illness coverage altogether. The best way to know for sure is to read the policy wording before buying.
Timing: When to Enroll a New Dog
One of the less recognized aspects of pet insurance for those who are new pet owners is the fact that many insurers state that enrolling before a pet’s first visit to a veterinarian is important and not just simply getting an early start with your enrollment, which means you should register your pet before his/her first appointment with the veterinarian.
The reason for this is the pre-existing condition clause that may be defined differently by different companies, but essentially it refers to a condition that was diagnosed before your policy came into effect or the expiration of the waiting period. Fetch’ FAQs also mentions that this includes “any accident or illness that occurred or your pet showed clinical signs of… before your pet’s first exam,” which further implies that even an informal notation in a medical record could later count as a pre-existing condition. ASPCA Pet Health Insurance also believes that it is best to enroll as soon as possible, ideally on the same day you bring your pet home.
The age at which one can enroll is also an important factor. According to Pumpkin, their minimum age for accepting puppies is eight weeks old, although this age can be different for each provider; it always makes sense to check a specific insurer’s eligibility page before concluding that puppies are eligible.
Free Trial Certificates From Breeders or Registration Programs
If you brought home your puppy from a professional dog breeder or registered your puppy with a kennel club, then you might have received a trial insurance certificate without knowing what it is. According to the American Kennel Club, the completion of the AKC registration usually comes with a 30-day certificate of accident and illness pet insurance without additional cost. Then it’s up to you as the puppy’s owner to activate it.
In addition, some insurance companies have programs designed exclusively for breeders that will only be active for a short period of time. For instance, the breeder program provided by Trupanion has a 24-hour activation period calculated when the puppy leaves the breeder. What is important is that the owner should do the activation; the breeder cannot do it on behalf of the owner.
The main idea is that if you got some paperwork of this nature but didn’t read it after taking your puppy home, it’s high time to check whether there is an activation period that you should meet, since in most cases they don’t activate automatically.
Waiting Periods, Including the Longer Orthopedic Wait
The waiting period is defined as the interval that starts from the activation of your policy to the time you can lodge a claim. U.S. News states that most illnesses have a waiting period of 14 days, but this time varies according to the insurance company.
However, what is not often mentioned is that orthopedic conditions have a distinct waiting period, which is usually longer than that for illnesses. U.S. News indicates that many major insurance providers impose waiting periods of more than 6 months for certain conditions such as hip dysplasia and also CCL/ACL injuries, which, by the way, are quite prevalent in many breeds that are mostly prone to them. For example, Insurify’s guide to hip dysplasia insurance states that some companies have waiting periods of 6 months, with options like Embrace and Fetch among them, while other companies do something different, with even one of the big providers stating that hip dysplasia is not covered altogether, depending on the plan.
Lemonade provides a potential situation to illustrate this point, whereby a German Shepherd puppy who starts limping during a 30-day orthopedic waiting period would have this situation marked as pre-existing, even though in the case of the same injury appearing after the waiting period, it would most likely be covered. Lemonade emphasizes that this example is hypothetical and is not meant to be interpreted as a real-life case.
One thing to consider is that if you are going for a breed that has a high risk of orthopedic injuries, such as large or giant breeds, it may make more sense to inquire with your potential insurer what the orthopaedic waiting period is, rather than making the generalization that it will be equal to that of the general illness waiting period.
Pre-Existing vs. Hereditary vs. Congenital Conditions
These three expressions are used near to each other. Nevertheless, they have different meanings, and the importance of those differences is especially evident in the case of breeds with recognized hereditary predispositions.
| Term | General Definition | Typical Coverage Pattern |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-existing | A condition that showed symptoms or was diagnosed before your policy’s effective date or during the waiting period | Generally excluded, in most cases permanently |
| Hereditary | A condition genetically passed down from a pet’s parents (e.g., hip dysplasia in some large breeds) | Often eligible for coverage if no symptoms existed before enrollment and the waiting period has passed |
| Congenital | A condition present at birth, which may or may not also be hereditary | Often eligible for coverage under the same no-prior-symptoms condition |
As mentioned in the explanation provided by MetLife Pet Insurance, “hereditary and congenital conditions can be part of our regular illness and accident policy.” The only requirement is that the pet should not show symptoms prior to signing a contract or during the waiting period; otherwise, the condition is considered pre-existing. Trupanion’s FAQ provides a similar explanation and points out the fact that “a lot of insurance companies restrict or even deny compensation for hereditary and congenital illnesses.”
The Bilateral Condition Exclusion
This exclusion is one of the more impactful ones in pet insurance terms, yet it is not something that comes up often when discussing the issue of “is pet insurance worth it” with clients.
“Bilateral condition” refers to a condition affecting both sides of a paired body part. Most commonly, this occurs with knees, hips, or eyes. Embrace has its own pet insurance glossary, and the affiliate explains that the term “bilateral exclusion” means that if one side suffers from a condition before or during the policy’s waiting period, the other side will be excluded from future coverage for the same type of condition even if it ends up suffering an injury after that waiting period.
According to MetLife’s blog, coverage for bilateral conditions may be possible under policies as long as it is not a case of a pre-existing condition, which would mean that the issue is not one of lack of coverage but rather a matter of timing. Embrace states that it “does not exclude bilateral conditions as long as the initial condition is not pre-existing.” There are differing practices regarding this field, and Fairer Finance conducted a UK review of many insurers that found that most insurers treat bilateral conditions as just one condition for the annual limit recharge, which implies that the coverage amount usually does not get doubled even if both sides require treatment.
This means in practice: if you insure a breed that has been known to get cruciate diseases (such breeds often include Labrador Retrievers, Golden Retrievers and Rottweilers), it can be useful to ask potential insurers whether their contract includes bilateral exclusions and what that means for them specifically or if that differs among companies.
How Reimbursement Actually Works
The reimbursement rate is usually shown as a large headline number, such as 70%, 80%, or 90%. However, what you could get back is potentially lower than what the percentage indicates due to a few elements that shape it.
Deductible timing
As stated by MoneyGeek’s reimbursement guide, the deductible is taken off prior to applying the reimbursement percentage, so that the amount on a $1,000 bill with an 80% reimbursement rate is $800 after subtracting the $200 deductible. If the $200 deductible has not yet been met, however, you will take home less.
Excluded line items
Although exam fees are excluded from the general accident-and-illness policy and are considered a wellness expense in the eyes of many insurers, meaning they will not count towards the reimbursed sum, the rest of the visit may still be covered.
Benefit schedules versus actual-cost reimbursement
A limited number of companies utilize a “benefit schedule,” meaning they have a set maximum amount that they will pay for each diagnosis regardless of the actual charges incurred at the vet. Embrace points out that “in large metropolitan areas, the payout according to the benefit schedule may be much lower than the real costs incurred,” resulting in policyholders needing to pay more out of pocket than what a percentage reimbursement obligation might require.
PetInsuranceQuotes explains that most of the larger providers now use percentage reimbursement instead of sticking to a fixed amount, though it is necessary to verify which measure a provider uses before taking for granted that the amount you will be reimbursed will equal the amount you were charged.
Premiums Can Change Over Time
Pet insurance premiums are usually not constant throughout the lifetime of the policy. The statistics on the industry provided by NAPHIA for the year 2026, as announced by Insurance Business, suggest growth in gross written premium of 20.8% in the American market for pet insurance for the respective period, which is far above the growth in the number of issued policies – which shows that average premiums and rates have increased considerably. The same document points out a state-level example in regard to this matter – for instance, the Florida authorities approved price hikes of the rates for pet insurance in late 2025; the average increase was 9.25%, while one company was given permission to raise its premiums by 26%.
In another consumer protection bulletin, the South Carolina Department of Insurance reviewed a Washington Post/Consumer Checkbook investigation that determined that premiums for different pets begin to rise only a couple of years after enrollment, simply due to the pet aging, which can make some policies no longer viable for some pet owners.
However, one should not think that every policyholder will encounter a significant rise in their rates. Such changes require proper regulation and depend upon the state, provider, and the pet’s individual history, and one should not consider that change in premium rates.
Is a Wellness Add-On Worth Considering?
Coverage for wellness is usually provided as an optional supplement, not a separate insurance product. It is usually intended to provide reimbursement for common services like routine checkups, vaccinations, and dental cleanings.
Whether you apply it depends on your analysis of the cost of the additional coverage versus what you would spend on routine services. Some commentators have indicated that wellness riders may be more expensive than the services they cover, as the insurer would be taking into account its own margin on predictable costs. This represents a good question worth considering but not yet proven true for every plan or provider. The differences in insurance pricing can result in various conclusions, so comparing the regular expenses of your pet with specific quotes for coverage will give you a more reliable answer.
Pet Insurance vs. Self-Insuring
Some pet owners may choose the option to self-insure their pets, which means that they set aside an amount each month equal to what they would be paying in pet insurance premiums into a separate savings account.
| Consideration | Pet Insurance | Self-Insuring (Savings Fund) |
|---|---|---|
| Access to funds in year one | Available once waiting periods clear | Limited to whatever has been saved so far |
| Predictability | Fixed monthly premium, though it may rise at renewal | Fully within your control |
| Unused funds | Not refunded if unused | Remain yours if never needed |
| Large early emergency | May be reimbursed, subject to policy terms | Could exceed savings if it happens early |
There is actually no right or wrong answer here since the deciding factor is the amount of money you can realistically set aside before some unexpected health emergency strikes your pet and how you think of a prospective huge vet bill in terms of risks and ongoing insurance premiums. Some owners opt for a compromise approach, i.e., they set aside a small emergency fund and purchase an accident-only insurance policy that is much cheaper than regular full accident and illness coverage.
Why Claims Get Denied (and What’s Genuinely Unknown)
Part of the reason that claims are denied frequently has to do with insurance firms’ classification of a condition as being pre-existing based on the definitions discussed in earlier sections of this manual. Policies that have incomplete waiting periods and that have blanket exclusions, such as the bilateral exclusion mentioned above, also come up frequently in the documentation of the major denial triggers.
It’s worth saying clearly that there does not seem to be any precise rate of claims denied in the area of pet insurance widely available to interested parties. Although there are many reports of percent rates of claims denied by pet insurance companies, a thorough investigation did not uncover any such source that would be steady and reliable, since any use of absolute numbers of denied claims should be thoroughly questioned if not logically proved otherwise through the state regulatory agencies or provider companies.
As a general guideline that could potentially bring the chances of getting claims denied lower, it’s advisable to keep your own medical records of your pet at your disposal and to use the same clinic if possible, thus creating a consistent medical history.
Ways Owners Sometimes Lower Premiums
In the industry, there are a couple of discount systems; however, not all of them are available from all companies.
- Multi-Pet Discounts. For instance, AKC Pet Insurance offers a 5% discount when you register multiple pets under one policy.
- Bundling with Homeowners/Renters Insurance. Some insurers offer rate cuts to policyholders of pet insurance who are already homeowners or renters with the same company.
- Breeder or Adoption Program Partnerships. Some breeders or breed clubs may take part in programs where discounts are available to their clients when they use certain insurance providers as noted in the AKC reference.
Since discount programs are subject to change and differ significantly from one company to another, it is highly advisable to check with a particular insurer directly rather than assume that a rate cut is available.
A Simple Decision Framework
There isn’t a cut-and-dried answer to whether or not a first-time dog owner ought to buy pet insurance — but it does vary according to individual situations. Here are a few things to consider:
- Can you comfortably meet an unexpected vet bill of between $3,000 and $7,000 without going through financial hardship? If you cannot, insurance or an emergency fund will lower that risk.
- Is your dog breed linked to potential hereditary or orthopedic problems? If yes, getting insurance sooner, ideally before any symptoms show, will be more important to you than it would be for an unspecified breed that does not have any specific medical predispositions.
- Do you favor predictable monthly payments (knowing that premiums may rise) or prefer to have control over the emergency fund you manage yourself?
- Have you compared quotes from different insurers and made sure to carefully check various waiting periods, exclusions, and payment methods instead of looking only at the average?
This article won’t tell you what is right for your dog, but it will help you analyze all these issues together with a particular policy in mind.
FAQ’s About Pet Insurance for First Time Dog Owners
Generally, no. Most providers exclude conditions that showed symptoms or were diagnosed before the policy’s effective date or during the waiting period, according to sources including PetMD and Healthy Paws. Some providers do offer coverage again for certain “curable” conditions after an extended symptom-free period, but terms vary by insurer.
Several insurers recommend enrolling before your dog’s first veterinary visit, since chart notes from that visit could affect what’s later classified as pre-existing. ASPCA Pet Health Insurance suggests enrolling “as early as possible, even as soon as the day you bring them home.”
A waiting period is the time between your policy’s start date and when you become eligible to file a claim. Standard illness waiting periods commonly run around 14 days, though this varies by insurer, while orthopedic-condition waiting periods (for issues like hip dysplasia or cruciate ligament tears) are often six months or longer, according to U.S. News.
It’s a policy provision where, if a paired body part (commonly a knee, hip, or eye) is affected on one side, the other side may also be excluded from future coverage for the same type of condition — even if the second injury happens after enrollment. Practices vary by insurer; some, like Embrace, state they don’t apply this exclusion as long as the initial condition wasn’t pre-existing.
It may, depending on the provider and timing. Coverage for hereditary and congenital conditions is often available if your pet wasn’t showing symptoms before enrollment and the waiting period has passed, according to MetLife and Trupanion. If symptoms existed before enrollment, the same condition would typically be treated as pre-existing instead.
Not necessarily. Your deductible is generally subtracted first, exam fees and other excluded items typically don’t count toward the reimbursed total, and a small number of providers use a fixed “benefit schedule” instead of a percentage of your actual bill. According to Embrace, benefit-schedule payouts “can be much less than the actual treatment cost” in some cases.
Not necessarily. Premiums are generally subject to change at renewal and often increase as a pet ages, according to industry data summarized by the South Carolina Department of Insurance. Recent industry-wide data also points to broader rate increases in some markets, according to NAPHIA data reported by Insurance Business.
This depends on your personal financial situation, your dog’s breed-related health risks, and your comfort with financial uncertainty — there isn’t a single correct answer for every owner. A Bankrate article citing an Experian survey reported that 92% of pet owners who have pet insurance said it was worth it, while only 29% of pet owners surveyed had a policy at all — a gap worth weighing against your own circumstances rather than treating either number as a directive.
📅 Last Updated:
Explore More Pet Insurance & First-Time Dog Owner Resources
Choosing pet insurance for the first time can be confusing, especially when you are also learning how to care for a new dog. Explore these related guides to understand puppy care, insurance options, preventive health, and the costs new pet owners should plan for.
Is Pet Insurance Worth It for a First-Time Pet Owner?
Understand the potential benefits and drawbacks of pet insurance before deciding whether coverage makes sense for your new dog.
How to Take Care of a Puppy at Home
Learn the essentials of feeding, training, hygiene, exercise, and daily care that every new puppy owner should understand.
Is Lemonade Pet Insurance Good for Puppies?
Review puppy-specific coverage, waiting periods, benefits, and important policy details before choosing Lemonade for a young dog.
How to Choose Pet Insurance in 2026
Learn how deductibles, reimbursement rates, annual limits, waiting periods, and exclusions can affect the value of a policy.
Pet Insurance for Emergency Vet Visits
Understand how emergency coverage can help protect new dog owners from unexpected veterinary expenses caused by accidents or sudden illness.
Complete Guide to Pet Insurance in the USA
Explore our comprehensive guide to compare providers, understand coverage, and make a more informed pet insurance decision for your dog’s long-term healthcare needs.
About the Author
M. Nouman is an independent researcher and writer focused on U.S. pet insurance. He reviews insurer policy documents, coverage terms, waiting periods, reimbursement options, exclusions, and publicly available veterinary and regulatory resources to create clear, research-based guides. His goal is to simplify complex insurance information so pet owners can make informed decisions based on reliable sources rather than marketing claims. Articles are reviewed and updated as policies and industry information change.
Areas of Research: Pet Insurance Policies, Coverage Analysis, Policy Comparisons, Waiting Periods, Reimbursement Models, Policy Exclusions, Claims Education